Commentary: Is "Black Girls" a Fetish Track?

A new song from the all-white group Chester French has some Blacks wondering if Black women are trophies to the group. You be the judge.

Posted: 04/25/2012 06:46 PM EDT

People are mad about pop music again.

Today, the rage is directed at a new song and music video from the Massachusetts band Chester French.  

The song: Black Girls

Sample lyric: “I've got a thing for Black girls / La la la la la, la la / La la la la la / Yeah, my mom says I've got a thing for Black girls.”

The video for the song depicts a white woman lip-syncing the track while dancing around a Black woman.

It’s pretty direct: You know what Chester French is saying. But is it offensive?

"We don’t know how to feel about this song and video,” writes the Urban Daily, a Black culture site. “Are Black women a fetish for them or what?”

Meanwhile, on Global Grind, hip hop mogul Russell Simmons’s website, the verdict on the video is decidedly lighter: “In effort to address the somewhat taboo topic of interracial relationships, Chester French created a bold and unabashed ode to celebrate Black women and their femininity.”

While I can understand people’s reflexive aversion to Black Girls, if I’m being honest, I think getting up in arms about the song is misguided.

For years, white male artists have been singing the praises of Black women. When Mick Jagger sang, “Ah, brown sugar, how come you taste so good,” back in 1971, he was not talking about sugar. And the Van Morrison song Brown-Eyed Girl was originally titled Brown-Skinned Girl. It was changed so as not to be too risqué on 1960s radio.

Black women, like all women, are beautiful, and acknowledging that beauty doesn’t automatically mean fetishization. As Chester French says at the beginning of its song: "This ain't no fetish / ain't objectifying no one."

Sometimes a song is just a song.

The opinions expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of BET Networks.

BET National News - Keep up to date with breaking news stories from around the nation, including headlines from the hip hop and entertainment world. Click here to subscribe to our newsletter. 

Videos You May Like

(Photo: Courtesy Interscope Records)

From Our Partners