Melanie Fiona shut the 2011 Soul Train Music Awards red carpet down in the Alexander McQueen coat ensemble she wore to host pre-show arrivals with AJ Calloway. As the singer got the rundown of what other celebs were wearing for the night, our eyes kept going back to the striking asymmetrical piece she paired with shorts and Wolford bondage tights (add those to our winter shopping list!).

Meanwhile, Kelly Rowland cozied up in the tailored coat while in Paris filming her newest video “Keep It Between Us” with Lance Gross. Kelly wore the piece with black skinny jeans and Giuseppe Zanotti boots with gold detailing. She pulled it all together with chunky gold bangles and earrings.

Vote in our poll and tell us who you think looked hotter.

(Photos: Kat Goduco/PictureGroup; Marc Piasecki/FilmMagic)