Appeals Court: Woman Pepper Sprayed by NYPD Can Sue for Excessive Force

Occupy Wall Street

Appeals Court: Woman Pepper Sprayed by NYPD Can Sue for Excessive Force

Imani Brown to go forward with civil suit stemming from 2011 arrest.

Published August 22, 2015

Imani Brown, who was pepper sprayed by an NYPD officer during a 2011 arrest, can sue for excessive force, a New York appeals court ruled Wednesday.

The Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan overturned an earlier decision to dismiss the civil suit Brown filed against Officers Justin Naimoli and Theaorode Plevritis this past June. The City Law Department is now reviewing the new court ruling.

According to Brown, she was trying to use a Starbucks bathroom on Nov. 15, 2011, leading to the altercation with Naimoli and Plevritis. The Occupy Wall Street protester claims one of the cops told her to “p**s in the park,” referencing  Zuccotti Park, the location of an OCW camp raided by NYPD raided hours earlier.

The cops claim they approached Brown after receiving a 911 call from a Starbucks employee about someone banging on the window. They assert that Brown refused to hand over her identification, which led to a struggle.  


Brown’s arrest was caught on tape, although the video picks up where officers are attempting to handcuff her, as she squirms. Officers yell back at  her to “Stop resisting!” several times, while she continues to wiggle her hands away.

As the two officers wrestle Brown to the ground, a crowd collects. “She wanted to use the bathroom at Starbucks, she was banging on the door asking them to let her use the bathroom, and they called the cops on her,” says a witness standing feet from Brown as the two officers try to get her cuffed, pushing her head into the concrete, while her skirt rides up.

Brown says she was trying to pull her skirt down when the officer pepper sprayed her the first time. She is pepper sprayed again, as more officers arrive and the crowd continues to swell.

Brown is then carted off to a squad car and is heard asking the officer to pull her skirt down. He allegedly replied: “No, it wouldn’t have been like that, if you weren’t causing trouble.”

All charges against Brown were later dropped.

BET National News - Keep up to date with breaking news stories from around the nation, including headlines from the hip hop and entertainment world.

Click here to enter the #LookYourSundayBest contest for a chance to win FREE natural hair-care products.

(Photo: Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

“The only excessive features of this case are the elaborate constitutionalization of the routine arrest of a disorderly individual, the unfair attack on the professional reputation of two NYPD officers, the absurd waste of judicial time that has ensued and will follow on remand, and the imposition on the valuable time of jurors."READ MORE:

Posted by New York Daily News on Thursday, August 20, 2015

Written by Latifah Muhammad


Latest in news