Afroman Testified In A Red, White And Blue Suit At His 'Lemon Pound Cake' Trial, And A Deputy Broke Down In Tears
The Afroman saga just keeps getting wilder.
The 51-year-old rapper, born Joseph Foreman, showed up to an Adams County, Ohio, courtroom this week dressed in a full red, white and blue suit, matching sunglasses and his signature coif to defend himself in a civil trial brought by the very sheriff's deputies who raided his home in August 2022. The charge from law enforcement? His viral hit "Lemon Pound Cake," built entirely from his own home surveillance footage of the botched raid, hurt their feelings.
Seven members of the Adams County Sheriff's Office are suing Foreman for defamation, invasion of privacy and intentional infliction of emotional distress over the music video, which has racked up more than 3 million views since its December 2022 release. The deputies claim that the video and related social media posts subjected them to public humiliation, ridicule and even death threats.
Here's the thing, though: the raid itself turned up absolutely nothing. Deputies rolled up on Foreman's Winchester, Ohio, home with weapons drawn, broke down his front gate, busted through a door and tore through the property based on a warrant citing probable cause for narcotics and kidnapping. No evidence of criminal activity was found. No charges were ever filed.
Foreman, who was in Chicago at the time, said his neighbors called to tell him police were swarming his property. When he reviewed his security footage, he did what any self-respecting artist would do: he turned it into a song.
The title "Lemon Pound Cake" came from one of the more absurd moments captured on camera, when a deputy appeared to pause mid-raid to check out a lemon pound cake Foreman's mother had baked, sitting on the kitchen counter.
"All of this is their fault," Foreman testified on Tuesday. "If they hadn't wrongly raided my house, there would be no lawsuit, I would not know their names, they wouldn't be on my home surveillance system, and there would be no songs … my money would still be intact."
Foreman also told the court that deputies disconnected his surveillance cameras during the search and that roughly $400 of his seized cash was missing when it was returned. An outside investigation conducted by Clermont County at the sheriff's office's request attributed the discrepancy to a "miscount."
A Deputy In Tears
The trial's most dramatic moment came on Monday, when Deputy Lisa Phillips took the stand. Phillips, who told the court she had been called in on her day off to help execute the warrant, broke down crying as the court played a 13-minute music video Foreman made that included pointed innuendos directed at her. She testified that the content subjected her to community ridicule and deeply personal accusations.
On Tuesday, Sgt. Randy Walters also testified about the harassment he says he experienced since the raid. When asked if he had been called a "son of a bitch," Walters confirmed he had, but noted it hadn't been published online. Hours after court adjourned that evening, Foreman posted a new video to his social media accounts: him singing "Randy Walters is a son of a b*tch."
The man is undefeated.
The Bigger Picture
This case has drawn attention well beyond southern Ohio. The ACLU filed an amicus brief in support of Foreman, arguing that the deputies' lawsuit threatens core First Amendment protections. The civil liberties organization stated that nothing the First Amendment protects more fiercely than criticism of public officials on matters of public concern.
The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) also weighed in, warning that a verdict against Foreman would send a "chilling" message to anyone who documents and criticizes police conduct.
Foreman's defense is straightforward: the footage was captured on his own property by his own cameras, and he has every right to use it. His legal team argues the case is fundamentally about free speech, not defamation.
Closing arguments are underway on Wednesday, with an eight-person jury set to decide whether Foreman's music falls within the bounds of protected expression or whether the deputies' claims of reputational harm warrant damages.
Either way, Afroman has already turned a failed police raid into one of the most compelling free speech cases in recent memory. And he did it in a flag suit.