Everyone but Andi and Penelope saw Gary's true nature. While he seemed kind to Penelope, his toxic behavior with Andi was evident from the start. Despite this, she couldn't break free, even pretending to move on to Jordan. In "Sistas," Andi and Penelope discovering each other, a tough situation for pregnant Penelope. Gary's actions, which should have led to a breakup, only worsened things. Let's explore five of Gary's worst moments with Andi.

Jasmine the Psycho Wife

It’s probably not fair to call Jasmine a psycho because she was married to Gary, after all. She may have entered that relationship perfectly sane, but Gary. Anyway, what we saw from her was wild, unstable behavior. Gary started a relationship with Andi and didn’t mention his marriage. Welp, Jasmine popped up and got Andi jumped and Fatima ended up saving Andi that time. Then Jasmine tried to kill Gary and Andi, while they were in bed, and it still wasn’t enough for Andi to walk away.

Choking Andi Out 

This is self-explanatory, but the first time Andi tried to rid herself of Gary, he decided to choke her out because his rationale was that if he couldn’t have her then no one could. 

The Photoshoot

Gary thought it was a good idea to stage an actual wedding set up as a photoshoot. He set it up as a surprise for Andi, got her girls to show up dressed as bridesmaids by lying to them too, and when Andi showed up, he pulled a switcheroo and tried to get the ceremony going. Thankfully, Andi declined, but who does that? 

Trying to Buy Andi’s Place of Business 

We still don’t know what Gary does for money other than scamming, but he does have money. He had the nerve to attempt to buy Andi’s pace of work so that he could keep an eye on her. That’s God levels of stalker. 

Penelope 

Finally, Andi finding out that Gary had a whole fiancee and baby on the way was also a hurtful surprise. Even worse is that Gary had the nerve to tell Penelope, in front of Andi, that Andi was just a side piece. We all know that wasn’t true, but ouch.