The story of Karmelo Sincere Anthony is one that’s stirred up emotions and divided opinions across Texas and beyond. Now, the 17-year-old has officially been indicted for first-degree murder in the death of fellow student Austin Metcalf—an incident that unfolded during a high school track meet on April 2, 2025, in Frisco.

Both boys were just 17 at the time. But under Texas law, that means they’re tried as adults.

On Tuesday (June 24), Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis announced the indictment, calling Metcalf’s death “a violent loss” that “shook the community.” According to Willis, prosecutors spent weeks presenting evidence to the grand jury before requesting the indictment.

What followed was a swift response: Anthony was formally charged and will now head to trial.

But while the DA's office pushes its narrative forward, Karmelo’s supporters are urging the public—and the justice system—to slow down and consider the full picture.

According to the police affidavit, tensions between the two teens reportedly began over a tent on a rainy day. Witnesses say Metcalf asked Anthony to move, and when he didn’t, things escalated. Anthony allegedly warned Metcalf not to touch him. When Metcalf put hands on him, Anthony reportedly pulled a knife from his backpack and stabbed him once in the chest.

Karmelo allegedly told officers at the scene, “I was protecting myself.” He also asked if what happened could be considered self-defense.

To many in the community, those words shouldn’t be dismissed.

“He’s not a monster,” a family friend said in a now-viral post defending Karmelo. “He was scared. He reacted in a moment where he felt threatened. He wasn’t trying to be a killer.”

Online, support for Karmelo has grown quickly. A legal defense fundraiser surpassed $500,000, and supporters have called for a fair trial and safe relocation, noting that Karmelo and his family have received threats since the incident.

He has since been released on $250,000 bail and allowed to graduate and receive his high school diploma—a move that sparked outrage from some, but relief for those who believe he deserves a shot at redemption.

District Attorney Willis made it clear that the justice process must be measured and principled. “We’re also mindful of Austin’s family, and everyone who loved him. Please keep them in your thoughts — and, if you’re willing, in your prayers as well.”

That call for compassion is one that many are extending to both sides. Because at the heart of this tragedy is a harsh reality: teenage boys full of potential, met at a crossroads that left one dead and the other fighting for his freedom.

The legal process is just beginning. And while Anthony, like all defendants, is presumed innocent until proven guilty, the question remains—how do we hold space for justice when there are no winners?

For now, Karmelo Sincere Anthony waits. And a community continues to reckon with grief, trauma, and the heavy weight of a system that too often sees Black youth through a distorted lens.