The Carter power matrimony that is genre-transcending worldwide superstar Beyoncé and hip-hop-slash-business aficionado Jay-Z have kept each crowd at their collaborative On The Run 2 Tour on edge since embarking on the worldwide excursion last week.

From their symbolic elevator entrance to thrillingly steamy PDA, from mugshots of criminal ghosts past all the way down to the Queen Bey’s iconic good-girl-gon-gangsta ensembles, the Carters are holding back nothing and laying everything on the stage. That hasn’t stopped fans from using the little that Bey and Hov left to the imagination for another chapter in the Beyhive’s favorite pastime: pregnancy rumors.

And after some internet-circulating, front-row footage of what fans believe to be the Lemonade songstress’s baby-bumped belly, the Beyhive has their hearts set on a fourth bun in Bey’s oven.  

See their theories, and rebuttals, below.